Just a short drive from Naples, Marco Island offers a delightful escape with its pristine beaches, stunning sunsets, and a dining scene that rivals the best in Southwest Florida. When giving dining recommendations to our luxury rental guests, we often recommend Marco Island for visitors who want to venture outside of Naples. Whether you're looking for fresh seafood, authentic Italian cuisine, or a laid-back beachside meal, Marco Island has something for every taste. Here are five best dining spots on Marco Island that you won't want to miss.
The Oyster Society
Website: The Oyster Society
Located in the heart of Marco Island, The Oyster Society is a premier dining destination for seafood lovers. This upscale restaurant combines a stylish, art-deco interior with a menu that highlights the freshest oysters and seafood available. In addition to their impressive selection of oysters from around the country, The Oyster Society offers dishes like the Lobster Bisque, Spanish Octopus, and the delectable Oceanic Platter, which is perfect for sharing. The elegant ambiance, creative cocktails, and live music make it an ideal spot for a special night out.
Osteria Capri
Website: Osteria Capri
Though technically located on the Isle of Capri, just a short bridge away from Marco Island, Osteria Capri offers an authentic Italian dining experience that is well worth the short drive. This charming, waterfront restaurant is known for its farm-to-table approach, featuring ingredients sourced from local farms and seafood straight from the Gulf. The menu includes house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and daily seafood specials, all crafted with a focus on traditional Italian flavors. Dine al fresco on their scenic patio and enjoy dishes like the Tagliatelle Cacio e Pepe, Zuppa Di Pesce or the Lamb Osso Bucco, paired with a glass of fine Italian wine.
Island Gypsy
Website: Island Gypsy
For a more casual dining experience, Island Gypsy is the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with a view. Located on the water's edge at the Isles of Capri Marina, this laid-back restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere where you can savor fresh seafood while watching boats glide by. The menu features a variety of crowd-pleasers, including Coconut Shrimp, Fish Tacos, and the “locally world famous” Grouper Sandwich. Check out the onion rings – they’re enormous. With its tiki-style decor, outdoor seating, and vibrant sunset views, Island Gypsy is the ideal place to kick back and enjoy the island life.
Quinn's on the Beach
Website: Quinn's
Quinn's on the Beach offers a quintessential beachfront dining experience at the JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort. This lively, open-air restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike, known for its tropical cocktails, delicious seafood, and unbeatable views of the Gulf of Mexico. The menu at Quinn's is a mix of Caribbean-inspired dishes and American classics, with highlights like the Carnitas Tacos, Rock Shrimp Ceviche and the Fish & Chips. As the sun sets, Quinn's transforms into a vibrant evening spot with tiki torches, live music, and a front-row seat to Marco Island’s breathtaking sunsets.
Davide Italian Cafe
Website: Davide Italian Cafe
For those craving authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy, welcoming environment, Davide Italian Cafe is a must-visit. This family-owned restaurant is a hidden gem on Marco Island, offering a menu filled with traditional Italian favorites made from recipes passed down through generations. From the rich and savory Lasagna Bolognese to the tangy Veal Piccata, every dish is prepared with passion and care. Davide Italian Cafe also features an impressive selection of wines and homemade desserts, making it the perfect spot for a leisurely meal with family or friends.
Marco Island is a culinary paradise just waiting to be explored. Whether you're in the mood for fresh seafood with a view, authentic Italian dishes, or a laid-back meal by the beach, these top dining spots offer something for everyone. On your next visit to Naples, make sure to book your luxury vacation stay with Naples Florida Rentals, and take a short trip to Marco Island and indulge in the delicious flavors that this beautiful island has to offer.